Slip & Fall

How to File a Slip and Fall Claim in the Bronx or New York City

The Law Offices of Evan W. Kohn 17 min read
How to File a Slip and Fall Claim in the Bronx or New York City

What should you do immediately after a Bronx slip and fall?

A slip and fall at a Bronx store, apartment building, sidewalk, or public property can leave you hurt, shaken, and unsure what to do first. This guide gives you an ordered path from medical care and reporting through evidence preservation, responsibility, deadlines, costs, and professional review.

Start with your health. Then protect the basic facts while they are still available. A wet floor may be cleaned, a broken step may be repaired, and a surveillance recording may be overwritten.

Use this sequence:

  1. Get emergency medical care for a serious injury and arrange appropriate follow-up for symptoms that continue or become more noticeable.
  2. Report the fall when possible and record where, when, and how it happened.
  3. Photograph the condition, surrounding area, and any visible injuries if you can do so safely.
  4. Collect witness information and preserve the shoes and clothing you wore.
  5. Identify who owned, occupied, managed, controlled, or maintained the property.
  6. Separate a private-property fall from a sidewalk, city, transit, housing, or other public-property fall.
  7. Review the possible deadline promptly instead of assuming that an incident report protects your legal rights.
  8. Organize your records before speaking with an insurer or seeking a case-specific evaluation.

You do not need to solve every legal question at the scene. You do need to create a clear record and avoid letting an early conversation or lost evidence decide the story for you.

How should you handle medical care, reporting, and insurer contact?

Medical care, an incident report, and careful insurance communication are the first response after a Bronx or New York City fall. If you suffer a serious injury, call 911 or seek emergency medical care. Symptoms from concussions, sprains, or spinal injuries may become more noticeable later, even if an injury initially seems manageable.

Do not treat the absence of immediate severe pain as a final medical assessment. Follow the advice you receive and keep the resulting records, including emergency-room paperwork, doctors’ notes, imaging reports, physical-therapy records, and medical bills.

Report the fall to the property owner or manager when possible. Ask for the appropriate incident-report process, provide a factual description, and keep a copy or note the date, recipient, and response. If the fall occurred on a sidewalk, in a public building, at a transit facility, or on another government-connected property, identify the agency or authority involved rather than assuming a private manager is responsible.

Avoid giving a recorded statement to an insurance company before speaking with a New York City slip-and-fall attorney. Do not guess about the condition, your symptoms, or the cause of the fall. If an insurer calls, write down the company, representative, date, and request, then obtain legal guidance before agreeing to a recorded interview.

We advise you to photograph the hazard, report the fall to the appropriate authority, obtain witness names and phone numbers, preserve your shoes and clothes, see a doctor, and speak with a lawyer before talking with an insurance company. These steps create a starting record; they do not determine responsibility by themselves.

An infographic checklist for the first response after a fall. It draws getting medical care, reporting the fall, documenting the hazard, and pausing recorded insurer contact.
A prompt, factual record can help organize the next steps after a fall.

What should you document at the location and afterward?

Your incident record should describe the location, the condition that caused the fall, your injuries, the witnesses, and what happened afterward. Potential hazards include wet floors without warning signs, broken staircases, icy walkways, uneven sidewalks, poor lighting, loose carpeting, and hazardous debris.

Take photographs close to the time of the fall to preserve the condition’s appearance and location before it disappears, is cleaned, or is repaired. Photograph more than the spot where you landed:

  • The hazard from several angles.
  • The surrounding floor, stairs, sidewalk, entrance, or walkway.
  • Warning signs, barriers, lighting, handrails, and visible maintenance problems.
  • The address, store sign, building entrance, or other location marker.
  • Visible injuries, torn clothing, or damaged personal items, when appropriate.

Ask witnesses for their names and phone numbers. Record where each person was standing and what each person observed without asking anyone to adopt your version of events. Obtain the incident-report number or a copy if the property representative provides one.

Preserve the shoes and clothing worn during the fall. Physical evidence such as those shoes or clothes may help confirm the presence of a hazard.
Gather photographs, witness information, incident reports, medical records, bills, and records of missed work or other financial losses. Keep emergency-room paperwork, doctors’ notes, imaging reports, physical-therapy records, medical bills, pay stubs, missed-shift records, employer correspondence, and other out-of-pocket-cost records in one folder. Add a short timeline with the date, place, symptoms, treatment, work impact, and communications connected to the fall.

An infographic checklist for documenting a fall. It draws photographing the scene, recording witnesses, keeping reports and records, preserving clothing, and creating a timeline.
A single organized folder can connect scene evidence with medical and financial records.

Who may be responsible for the property condition?

The potentially responsible property party may be an owner, landlord, tenant, store, building manager, maintenance contractor, public agency, or another party connected to the premises. Liability for an unsafe condition must be tied to ownership, occupancy, control, or special use of the premises.

In New York, landowners generally owe people on their property a duty of reasonable care. That principle does not identify the responsible party in every fall. Check who controlled the area, who maintained it, who had authority to repair it, and whether a lease or public-property arrangement affects those duties.

A sidewalk fall requires a separate responsibility check. In many New York City sidewalk cases, the adjacent property owner rather than the City is responsible for maintenance. Responsibility may differ for tree pits, city-owned property, and one- or two-family homes. Record the exact sidewalk location, the adjacent address, nearby signs, and whether the area was connected to a public facility.

Records about control and knowledge can matter. A New York court may find a triable issue about notice when the evidence shows, for example, that a property representative visited about 10 times since 1988 and knew the condition existed. That example concerns the evidence in that case; it is not a rule that every property visit establishes responsibility.

Write down every possible connection to the location before choosing a filing path. A store employee’s report, a landlord’s name, a building superintendent, a sidewalk address, or a public-agency sign may help identify who should receive notice and who needs to be investigated.

What does notice of a dangerous condition mean in New York?

Notice of a dangerous condition concerns whether the responsible property party knew or should have known about the condition before your fall. Actual notice means the party knew about it; constructive notice means the party should have known about it. The question is separate from proving that a hazardous condition existed.

A New York slip-and-fall case generally requires proof of four connected points:

  1. The property party owed you a duty of care.
  2. A dangerous condition existed.
  3. The party had actual or constructive notice of the condition.
  4. The condition caused your injury.

A claim may be available when a responsible property party created a dangerous condition or had actual or constructive notice of it and failed to address it within a reasonable time. Evidence may therefore focus on how the condition appeared, how long it existed, who saw it, what inspections occurred, and whether complaints or repairs were recorded.

Notice is often the most contested part of a New York slip-and-fall case. Your photographs, witness accounts, incident report, maintenance records, inspection information, surveillance, and medical timeline may each address a different part of the question.

Do not describe a guess as a fact. If you did not see how long the spill, ice, debris, broken surface, or other condition existed, record what you observed and identify people or records that may supply the missing context. The available facts must be evaluated together.

How can you preserve evidence before it disappears?

Evidence preservation begins with saving what you already have and identifying records that another person or business controls. A slip-and-fall case may be supported by accident photos, witness statements, medical records, incident reports, and maintenance logs even without surveillance footage.

Save original photographs and videos in more than one location. Keep the original files rather than relying only on cropped images or screenshots. Preserve texts, emails, letters, incident-report copies, medical bills, and work records in their original form, and make a dated list of anything you send or receive.

Retail surveillance systems may overwrite recordings within days or weeks, before a lawsuit is filed. If the fall happened in a store, lobby, garage, apartment building, or other monitored location, identify the cameras and request prompt preservation through appropriate legal channels. Do not assume that a property’s failure to hand you a video means no recording exists.

A lawyer can send a retailer a formal written demand to preserve surveillance footage, incident reports, and related records connected to your fall. That type of preservation letter identifies the incident and asks the retailer to retain relevant material while the claim is evaluated.

Once litigation is reasonably anticipated, a duty to preserve relevant evidence may arise; destroying evidence may support sanctions or an adverse inference. New York CPLR § 3101(i) requires full disclosure of films and videotapes involving a party, including all portions rather than only selected clips. Because those legal consequences depend on the circumstances, do not make accusations about missing footage; preserve your own records and obtain prompt advice about the records held by others.

Which deadline questions should you check first?

The first deadline question is whether the responsible party is private, municipal, another public corporation, or the State of New York. Do not use the private-property period as a default for a fall involving a public facility, sidewalk, housing authority, transit authority, or other government-connected location.

Most New York slip-and-fall lawsuits must be filed within three years of the fall, but that general period does not answer every case-specific timing question.

A lawsuit filed after the applicable statute of limitations expires will generally be dismissed, and missing a notice-of-claim deadline can end a case against a public entity.

The applicable deadline also depends on whether the owner is private or governmental, whether you were a minor, and whether your injuries affected your capacity. Reporting the accident to a property owner or manager does not extend the deadline for starting legal proceedings.

Write the fall date at the top of your file, then identify the property owner or agency and any required notice. Treat a possible public-entity fall as a prompt deadline issue even if you have not yet confirmed who controlled the location. Get a qualified New York legal review rather than waiting for an incident report, insurer response, or medical treatment to finish.

What changes when the fall involves a public entity or sidewalk?

Public-property and sidewalk falls require you to identify the specific government entity and the rule connected to that entity. A fall near a public place is not automatically a claim against New York City, and a sidewalk next to a private building is not automatically a claim against the adjacent owner.

If the responsible entity is the City of New York or another public corporation, a notice of claim usually must be filed within 90 days, and the lawsuit within 1 year and 90 days from the fall. For a fall on New York City-owned property, file a Notice of Claim with the NYC Comptroller within exactly 90 days from the accident; missing the deadline may permanently eliminate the right to sue the City.

Public property can include a New York City Housing Authority building or a New York City Transit Authority station. For those locations, the cited New York City guidance states that you must file a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the accident. Identify the building, station, platform, entrance, sidewalk, or other precise location and preserve signs, maps, photographs, and agency information.

If the responsible entity is the State of New York, a claim or notice of intention to file a claim generally must be served within 90 days, and the deadline to sue is 2 years from the fall if the notice of intention was served in time. That schedule differs from the City and many public corporations.

If a public defendant is involved in a wrongful-death claim after a fall, a notice of claim generally must be filed within 90 days of the estate representative’s appointment, and the deadline to sue is 2 years from the date of death.

Sidewalk responsibility may depend on the adjacent property, a tree pit, city ownership, or a one- or two-family home. Take prompt legal action to identify the correct entity and notice procedure instead of sending a general report to whichever office is easiest to find.

What should you gather before contacting an insurer or attorney?

Your consultation file should give a clear account of the fall without requiring you to explain every detail from memory. You do not need every listed type of evidence to pursue a slip-and-fall settlement. Bring what you have, label what is missing, and explain how you tried to obtain it.

Use this checklist:

  • Your full name and contact information.
  • The date, approximate time, and exact Bronx or New York City location.
  • A short description of the surface, object, spill, ice, lighting, stairs, sidewalk, or other condition.
  • Photographs and videos of the hazard, surrounding area, injuries, and location markers.
  • Names and phone numbers for witnesses, employees, managers, building staff, or responding personnel.
  • An incident report, police report, agency report, or your notes about when and to whom you reported the fall.
  • Emergency-room paperwork, doctor’s notes, imaging, therapy records, prescriptions, and medical bills.
  • Pay stubs, missed-shift records, employer correspondence, and other financial-loss records.
  • The shoes and clothing worn during the fall, preserved rather than altered.
  • Insurance letters, claim numbers, messages, recorded-statement requests, and settlement communications.
  • The owner, tenant, manager, agency, or public facility you believe may be connected to the property.
  • The fall date and any possible notice or filing deadline.

We investigate cases by gathering police reports, photographs, witness statements, and medical records. Your organized file helps identify what needs to be requested, what facts remain disputed, and which responsibility or timing questions require closer evaluation.

What does it typically cost to pursue a New York slip-and-fall claim?

The cost of pursuing a New York slip-and-fall claim depends on the written fee arrangement, the stage of the matter, case expenses, and whether separate insurance benefits are involved. A personal-injury lawyer may collect a contingency fee only if the case succeeds. A contingency fee is not paid upfront or on an hourly basis; payment is contingent on recovering for the injuries.

The ordinary percentage is 33%. A contingency fee can be less or use a sliding scale, such as 50% of the first $10,000 recovered, 33% of the next $40,000, and 20% of everything over $50,000. Those figures describe examples of fee structures, not a quote for your matter.

Ask these questions before signing:

  • Is the percentage the same before and after a lawsuit begins?
  • Is the percentage calculated before or after specified expenses are deducted?
  • Which filing, medical, expert, records, or investigation expenses may be advanced?
  • What happens if there is no recovery?
  • Does the arrangement cover a liability claim, no-fault benefits, or both?

A contingency arrangement may reduce the need for an upfront legal payment, but it does not mean every expense or insurance benefit follows the same fee rule. Read the written retainer with those distinctions in mind.

A bar chart infographic showing New York contingency-fee percentages: 50% of the first $10,000, 33% of the next $40,000, and 20% of everything over $50,000.
Contingency-fee examples can use different percentages at different recovery levels.

Which expenses and deductions should you ask about before retaining counsel?

The lawyer’s percentage is only one part of the financial arrangement. The lawyer’s percentage is deducted from the recovery after certain fees and disbursements are deducted. Fees and disbursements may include expert witnesses, medical exams, tests, filing fees, records, and other case expenses.

Ask for a plain explanation of the order of deductions:

  1. Which expenses may be paid or advanced while the case proceeds?
  2. Are those expenses deducted from a recovery before the percentage is calculated?
  3. Which expenses remain your responsibility if there is no recovery?
  4. How are medical liens, reimbursement obligations, or other claims handled?
  5. Will a separate arrangement apply to no-fault or other first-party insurance benefits?

If you recover, fees and disbursements are deducted from the recovery before the lawyer takes the percentage. If you do not recover, your obligation to pay case expenses is spelled out in the written retainer agreement. That agreement should answer the question directly rather than leaving the cost of an unsuccessful matter unclear.

The contingency-fee rules described here do not apply to fees for collecting no-fault, first-party insurance benefits. No-fault benefit collection generally follows a different fee structure under insurance regulations. Case expenses, such as filing fees or expert costs, are usually separate from the lawyer’s percentage fee, and medical liens and other reimbursement obligations are handled separately from the lawyer fee calculation.

Bring any health-insurance, no-fault, workers’ compensation, or medical-billing correspondence to the discussion. Do not assume that one fee percentage covers every part of the financial issues created by the fall.

How should you understand the amount that may remain after a recovery?

The amount that may remain after a recovery depends on the starting amount, the expenses deducted, the lawyer’s fee calculation, and any remaining claims. Ask for each stage instead of treating a settlement headline as the amount you would receive.

The basic terms are:

  • Gross settlement: the total settlement before fees, expenses, or other deductions.
  • Net recovery for the fee: the recovery after applicable case expenses are deducted under the governing rule.
  • Take-home check: the amount left after the fee and any remaining expenses or claims are paid.

For example, a proposed resolution may have a gross figure that does not equal the amount used to calculate the fee or the amount ultimately paid to you. Medical liens, reimbursement obligations, case expenses, and the written retainer may affect the calculation separately.

Ask for a written distribution statement before accepting or approving a resolution. The statement should show the gross amount, each expense, the amount used for the fee, the lawyer’s percentage, any lien or reimbursement payment, and the amount remaining. If no recovery has been reached, use the same questions to understand how a future recovery would be calculated.

Do not compare two proposed amounts until you know whether both figures are gross settlements, net recoveries, or take-home amounts. The label matters because each term measures a different stage of the distribution.

When should you seek a prompt professional evaluation?

A prompt professional evaluation is appropriate when the fall presents a serious injury, a disputed account, a government connection, or a possible short notice period. Serious symptoms deserve medical attention first; legal review can then address the property, evidence, insurance, and deadline questions together.

Seek prompt legal review if:

  • You suffered a serious injury or symptoms are worsening or becoming more noticeable.
  • The property owner, manager, insurer, or witness disputes how the fall occurred.
  • The fall happened on New York City-owned property, in a New York City Housing Authority building, at a New York City Transit Authority station, or at another public facility.
  • The fall occurred on a sidewalk and you do not know whether the City, an adjacent property owner, or another party is responsible.
  • A public entity may be involved and a 90-day Notice of Claim may apply.
  • An insurer requests a recorded statement, release, or immediate resolution.
  • Surveillance, incident reports, maintenance records, or other evidence may disappear.
  • You were a minor or your injuries affected your capacity, which may change the deadline analysis.

Reporting the fall does not extend the deadline for starting legal proceedings. Do not wait for an insurer’s position or a complete medical recovery before addressing a possible notice or filing period.

The Law Offices of Evan W. Kohn offers free consultations and operates 24/7. We serve clients in the Bronx and can arrange visits at home or in the hospital when travel is difficult. Bring the incident file and identify the questions that remain unresolved.

What should you bring to a Bronx slip-and-fall consultation?

A Bronx slip-and-fall consultation file should contain the fall date and location, photographs of the cause of the injury, witness names and phone numbers, incident and medical records, financial-loss records, insurance communications, the possible responsible party, and the deadline questions you have identified.

Bring the original photographs, preserve the shoes and clothes, and separate what you personally observed from what someone else told you. Include a short list of questions about notice, public-entity responsibility, surveillance, recorded statements, fees, expenses, liens, and no-fault benefits. A contingency-fee arrangement does not necessarily cover every part of a claim; an important exception may apply.

This article provides general information, not legal advice. A qualified New York attorney must evaluate your individual facts, responsibility issues, evidence, deadlines, and fee arrangement.

The Law Offices of Evan W. Kohn serves Bronx clients and can arrange a home or hospital visit when you cannot travel. Use the prepared information to request the next discussion about your fall and possible claim.


What practical questions should you ask before filing a Bronx slip-and-fall claim?

How can I file a slip and fall claim if I have not identified the responsible party?

Start by recording the exact location, property name or address, nearby signs, and the people or agencies connected with the area. Responsibility may involve an owner, tenant, manager, maintenance party, adjacent sidewalk property owner, or public entity. Do not assume the first person who receives your report is the correct defendant; identify the party with ownership, occupancy, control, or maintenance duties and check whether a public-entity notice procedure applies.

Can I pursue a slip-and-fall claim without surveillance footage?

Yes, a claim may still be supported by photographs, witness statements, medical records, incident reports, maintenance logs, and the shoes or clothing worn during the fall. Missing video does not automatically end the matter. Preserve your own evidence and request prompt preservation of any recording because retail systems may overwrite footage within days or weeks.

Does reporting a fall to the property manager protect the filing deadline?

No. An incident report documents what happened but does not extend the time to begin legal proceedings. Private and public properties can have different deadlines, and a public-property fall may require a Notice of Claim within 90 days. Identify the responsible entity and verify the applicable deadline promptly.

What should I confirm in a contingency-fee agreement for a slip-and-fall case?

Confirm the percentage, when it applies, how expenses are deducted, who pays case costs if there is no recovery, and how medical liens or reimbursement claims are handled. Ask whether separate terms apply to no-fault or other first-party benefits. Read the written retainer so you understand the difference between the lawyer’s fee, case expenses, and other deductions.


Hurt like this?

We handle Slip & Fall cases in the Bronx.

Evan W. Kohn, Esq. — more than 35 years of Bronx personal-injury practice. Reading about it only goes so far; a free consultation tells you what actually applies to your case.

Free consultation

Tell us what happened

Someone from the firm will call you back. It takes about a minute.

  • Free consultation. No fee unless we win.
  • We answer 24/7 — English and Spanish.
  • Home and hospital visits available.

Prefer to talk now? (718) 409-5500

Free and confidential. No fee unless we win. We answer 24/7.